Wario Star Missions:

1.) Smack more than 2 hits in a game! 2.) Become a captain and win more than 900 coins! 3.) Get a Gnarly Garlic! 4.) Get a hit with Mario! 5.) Pitch and bat with the Phony Ball and win the game! 6.) Strike out Mario! 7.) Get a red gem in Chain Chomp Sprint! 8.) Get more than 200 coins in the Toy Field! 9.) Belt a home run with Mario! 10.) Get more than 5 RBIs in the game!

Waluigi Star Mission:

1.) Strike 'em out! 2.) Win MVP!! 3.) Get a Whiskered Eggplant! 4.) Win with a shutout! 5.) Strike out Luigi! 6.) Get a runner out with a laser beam throw! 7.) Smack more than 3 hits in a game! 8.) Clear all minigames!

Magikoopa Star Missions:

1.) Drop a sacrifice bunt! 2.) Strike 'em out! 3.) Make a big play with a magical catch! 4.) Win MVP!!

Boo Star Missions:

1.) Smack a hit! 2.) Get 3 strikeouts in a game! 3.) Smack more than 2 hits in a game! 4.) Win with a shutout!

King Boo Missions:

1.) Smack a hit! 2.) Get a Team Star! 3.) Smack a hit with a charge swing! 4.) Make a jumping catch! 5.) Hit a home run! 6.) Be the MVP in the last game!

Petey Piranha Missions:

1.) Crack a long hit! 2.) Place first in Piranha Panic! 3.) Hit a home run! 4.) Shut out Mario's team and win! 5.) Crush someone with a body check! 6.) Catch the ball more than 5 times in a game!