Yeah thats a fair point and now that you've said that I'm thinking about it, it would definitely cause a few problems

and @PricelessNightmare Awesome!

These are really good rules except I don't think that getting other random shines should be allowed, I think it should just be the shines from the islands

Thanks! That means a lot

I actually got the idea from that category and yea the name was the first thing I could think of that fitted

Happy to hear that

I'm glad you like the idea!

An All Island category where the objective is to get all 5 shines from each island. This would start on a new save file and end when the final shine is obtained. I don't know how good of a category this would be but I really like the sounds of it