Request: Changes to Subcategories and Filter Variables
7 years ago
United States

When choosing to separate similar speedrun categories with slight variations, the two options are variables and subcategories. I feel variables are more suited to an extremely tiny difference in the run, while subcategories are more suited to a category that remains in the same vein as others, but differs substantially in its content.

One problem I have with variables is how their menus are universally shown across a game page. Even if there is a variable that only applies to a single category, the dropdown menu is still visible when other category tabs are selected. I think there should be an option to restrict a filter variable to only show up when certain category tabs are selected.

One of the benefits of variables is that speedruns can be filtered by a single variable or by showing speedruns of all variables integrated together. Arguably, subcategories are a more logical and aesthetically-pleasing option to separate speedrun categories, since they are shown up front on visible tabs and do not require navigating an unwieldy "filter" menu. One reason I believe subcategories are used less often, despite these factors, is that subcategories cannot be compared together. A change I request is an optional "All" tab that can be chosen to be shown along with the subcategories, that would put the times of all the subcategories together for comparison. An even better option would be the ability to select certain subcategories, not necessarily all of them, and then integrate those together for comparison, similar to selecting online shopping items and comparing their prices.
Edited by the author 7 years ago
HowDenKing, Lui and 6 others like this
United States

Variables need split out of the menu on larger resolutions. It's a high priority issue. I also agree with the sentiment of "all" for an optional user override for subcategories.