So I submitted a Blue Yourself Custom Items run like 2 weeks ago as a joke (it was last on the leaderboard). It got approved and it's on the leaderboard now. I did not include the VS Race settings screen for this run, as the rules say, "Please include the VS race settings screen, although this is not required. " More recently, I submitted a non-joke run to Blue Yourself Custom Items, also without the VS Race settings screen. It got rejected for not having the VS Race settings screen. Is this my fault?

Video proof is under 5 seconds for Blue Yourself custom items. As your time on the leaderboard was over 5 seconds, the video proof was not required, meaning that not having the VS Race settings was ok. Your rejected time was under 5 seconds, aka it required full video proof (full video proof needs VS race settings).