Howdy, and thanks for the suggestion!

The Mod team has been discussing making changes similar to what you've proposed, most likely being the addition of a new category for a more true "Any%" that won't require all three pieces of evidence (Or two in Nightmare mode).

As another mod, Dubzyhs, said on our Discord a couple of days ago, "We've been working hard on figuring out the logistics behind it since we want it to be a fair experience for all runners and create a ruleset where there is consistency between runs. We are not 100% guaranteed to add this category, but if it were to be added it would be around the time of the next update."

The goal would be to allow runners to have an opportunity to use game knowledge and potentially deduction (Particularly in Standard runs -- those being Professional, Intermediate, and Amateur) to correctly guess the ghost, and for the recording of the run to clearly show how they came to the conclusion of which ghost they are dealing with so it's evident that they aren't just throwing darts at the journal in hopes that they guess correctly.

Thanks for the feedback, and rest assured that it's a topic we've actively been talking about and working on finding the best way to implement it.

~Bravo