Kommentarer
United StatesFatMan9228 years ago

Go back in your grave

tac23tac23 tycker om detta
United StatesFatMan9228 years ago

How much is the time? The time for Into The Jungle is like close to 4 so it needs to be significant in my opinion to be worth seperation

United StatesFatMan9228 years ago

Alright yeah that's it thread is being locked as all this is doing is further proving the toxicity of this community

Crafter is not being banned

tac23tac23, ThermalGodlike, och tiggz16 gillar detta
United StatesFatMan9228 years ago

https://gyazo.com/e88880a3970c4a7313fdaeb84565089a

Refer to reason 1

With how rude you've been I'm considering punishment for you because even if he cheats he's still a person and you should respect him as one. I am not banning him for this. I may lock this thread soon but feel free to respond before that

United StatesFatMan9228 years ago

I'll revert back to reason 1 as it's the most important

"I have not found this issue on any of the runs submitted on speedrun.com. That means to me that the cheated runs are either a test, he doesn't want it official, or some other thing. "

If you don't want to consider the runs which are slowed down legit then go ahead because we haven't even been given opportunity to look at them. We're not gonna ban him from speedrun.com until he actually does such acts on speedrun.com. Even then, instead of outright banning him, we're probably just gonna retime with penalty. Bringing in #2, I really don't think that timer slow-down is something that is ban-worthy even if it's intentional, because it's such a piss-poor method that it can be resolved manually (You can't properly time a sped up video).

You people's main issue is that you hate how he acts about it, and that seems to be the reason you want him banned so bad. As a mod, I really should not bring emotion into things, and rather focus on fact. That is why I never banned Thunder (Even when I had feasible evidence against him). When considering I will not be thinking about how he acts.

As for talking to crafter tiggz is already doing that and I may consider having a direct conversation with him. Until then, no ban, because he hasn't even brought the issue to speedrun.com and it's for something as naive as slowing down a timer and gloating about it

United StatesFatMan9228 years ago
  1. I have not found this issue on any of the runs submitted on speedrun.com. That means to me that the cheated runs are either a test, he doesn't want it official, or some other thing.

  2. I VERY highly doubt that I'm gonna ban someone for slowing-down a timer; I am more likely to do so for speeding up runs than slowing down timers.

  3. The way you presented your evidence is very poor; no links to used videos for reference (I was able to find them and I am aware I didn't do that in my original Razor proof but I realize now that's a problem (I'm still not unbanning Razor because we have much more proof since then)), nothing is explained and I was generally a bit confused about what was going on. Next time maybe make it clearer, because bans need to be almost doubtless in necessity.

I am probably not banning crafter for this. If me and crafter get in touch I'll try to talk to him about this, but otherwise feel free to stop unless you have proof of speeding up

United StatesFatMan9228 years ago

Since the poll we've concluded that

  1. Noone has a really strong opinion, but many have an opinion.
  2. Many people seem to want single categories along the list of single-player categories to be disallowed waiting, and noone can decide which one that is
  3. Everyone is fine with disallowance for warper and kitless

My verdict is that we stick with the rules I made. There were valid reasons for the disallowance of some of the categories (Disruptor, Digger) but the reasoning doesn't seem enough to justify disallowance. Therefore, these are the rules in place as of now:

  1. For all single-player categories, spawn-waiting is permitted as it is difficult to enforce and we've accepted parts of it in the past. This includes Disruptor and Digger, as well as the less useful Helpless, and Jumper

  2. As a result of arbitrary times based on how long you can wait at the start, for 2 player categories (Kitless and Warper), we will disallow spawn-waiting; that means you need to sprint-start. If you end up waiting due to forgetfulness I would say make the timer start when your lower timer reaches 0.0

United StatesFatMan9228 years ago

To Paris' response, I only included Jumper and Helpless for completeness. It's obvious that spawn waiting has no effect but I want to make sure it's concise

tac23tac23 tycker om detta
United StatesFatMan9228 years ago

Edited date of closing to Thursday, 15:00 EST

tac23tac23 tycker om detta
United StatesFatMan9228 years ago

After someone made it apparent, we have realized that a significant flaw with our previous rule set is that for Warper and Kitless it would create runs that would start based on one point of view and end based on another, which would create obvious errors, as a result, we realized we need to either outright allow or disallow it for those 2 categories. This is the set we've decided:

  1. For all single-player categories, spawn-waiting is permitted as it is difficult to enforce and we've accepted parts of it in the past. This includes Disruptor and Digger, as well as the less useful Helpless, and Jumper

  2. As a result of arbitrary times based on how long you can wait at the start, for 2 player categories (Kitless and Warper), we will disallow spawn-waiting; that means you need to sprint-start. If you end up waiting due to forgetfulness I would say make the timer start when your lower timer reaches 0.0

Poll link: https://www.surveymonkey.com/r/TMZ87NR

(Note for the third question: Don't try to fill up as much space as possible; just answer concisely and honestly. The reason the third question is there is to prevent unjustified votes / votes which are persuaded by other parties)

Maax och tac23tac23 gillar detta
United StatesFatMan9228 years ago

Close poll on Wednesday 3 PM EST I reckon

tac23tac23 tycker om detta
United StatesFatMan9228 years ago

Thunder left so tiggz is never gonna resign Kappa

tac23tac23 tycker om detta
United StatesFatMan9228 years ago

I wish you the best. Good luck with school and life

tac23tac23 och Maax gillar detta
tråd: Portal 2
United StatesFatMan9228 years ago

I've known trustworthy programs that get identified as a virus on antiviruses. I would still assume it's more likely a false positive than an actual virus

United StatesFatMan9228 years ago

I don't want to add subjective things (such as rampages / streaks) to avoid the fundamental error with Flare's version

As for Sandstorm and Fungi Galore map edits I may consider strawpolling since (even though it's really insignificant) people seem to want it

tiggz16 tycker om detta
tråd: Portal 2
United StatesFatMan9228 years ago

No they're talking about livesplit autosplitter

tråd: Portal 2
United StatesFatMan9228 years ago

Jonese is trusted from what I know it is most likely a false positive

United StatesFatMan9228 years ago

When verifying runs for that I just assume that they put it into the right category (which they clearly did not here). It's fixed now

tac23tac23 tycker om detta
United StatesFatMan9228 years ago

Don't think map edits are worth the mention tbh

United StatesFatMan9228 years ago

Me and tiggz have decided to remove the Fungi Galore times as a result of a change in the map's design, making it longer in all categories. Sorry for the inconvenience (if this somehow inconvenienced anyone)

tac23tac23, tiggz16, och Paris_Labrador gillar detta
Om FatMan922
Gick med
9 years ago
Online
2 days ago
Körningar
187
Spel körda
Portal 2
Portal 2
Senaste körning 6 years ago
45
Körningar
Mirror's Edge
Mirror's Edge
Senaste körning 1 year ago
41
Körningar
Dragon Escape
Dragon Escape
Senaste körning 7 years ago
27
Körningar
Edgecraft
Edgecraft
Senaste körning 4 years ago
15
Körningar
Mirror's Edge Category Extensions
Mirror's Edge Category Extensions
Senaste körning 5 years ago
11
Körningar
Sparkour
Sparkour
Senaste körning 6 years ago
8
Körningar
Quantum Conundrum
Quantum Conundrum
Senaste körning 5 years ago
7
Körningar
Valley
Valley
Senaste körning 6 years ago
7
Körningar
Följda spel
Mirror's Edge
Mirror's Edge
Senaste besök 2 days ago
3,995
besök
Mirror's Edge Category Extensions
Mirror's Edge Category Extensions
Senaste besök 1 year ago
378
besök
Valley
Valley
Senaste besök 1 year ago
277
besök
Washing Machine Simulator 2001
Washing Machine Simulator 2001
Senaste besök 5 years ago
60
besök
Quantum Conundrum
Quantum Conundrum
Senaste besök 2 years ago
302
besök
There is no Learning Curve
There is no Learning Curve
Senaste besök 3 years ago
123
besök
Portal 2 Category Extensions
Portal 2 Category Extensions
Senaste besök 2 years ago
200
besök
Sparkour
Sparkour
Senaste besök 3 years ago
134
besök
Modererade spel
Edgecraft
Edgecraft
Senaste åtgärd 10 months ago
7
åtgärder
Sparkour
Sparkour
Senaste åtgärd 6 years ago
4
åtgärder
There is no Learning Curve
There is no Learning Curve
Senaste åtgärd 7 years ago
3
åtgärder
Just Dash
Just Dash
Senaste åtgärd 3 years ago
2
åtgärder