As a verifier for other Granny games, I would say the rule with "Time starts when Day 1 appears" adds unreasonable amount of seconds for no reason on all runs. The rule should be modified where the time starts when the player can move (That is when the white dot in the middle of the screen appears)
Still, the times on Speedrun.com shall be as accurate as they can possibly be for all submitted runs. Adding the cutscene as part of the speedrun goes against this idea entirely
If you guys want the dot as time i will start retime the runs from boards now. But before this check the beggining from both runs to see that "dot hud" difference. You can pause the video and use " . " or " , " to see frame by frame
example 1 *(Dot Hud appears after 3 frames when the fade out happen)
example 2* (Dot Hud appears the SAME time with fade out)