Super Mario World Forum  /  Explicit thresholds on not having video?
  Scrub_RTAScrub_RTA
(edited: )

Is there a specific time such that having video is required for a submission (i.e. sub-40:00 in all castles or sub-12:00 in 11 exit)? If not, how is it exactly decided?

Also, are videos without in-game audio treated with the same regard as submissions without video? I see in the general rules that "submissions require video" but "videos must have in-game audio".

 
  delcaMXdelcaMX

https://www.speedrun.com/smw/thread/f7cr2

A video and/or splits are not required, but are very heavily suggested. Runs without any sort of proof are up to the moderators’ discretion on whether they are verified or rejected. However, if a video is provided, it must be concise. That is, the video should only contain the run being submitted, and not an entire night’s broadcast for example. The run should start within 30 seconds of the beginning of the video, and the video should end after the credits or after resetting and file checking for the number of exits completed. The video should also contain the game audio. If the video supplied doesn’t meet this criteria your run may be rejected. If you do not have the capability to record video of your speedrun, consider recording your splits and submitting those.

 
  Scrub_RTAScrub_RTA

Yes, I saw that and I mentioned it. It's not clear what that means--are moderators allowed to "no vid no did" even the worst runs? Are videos without audio worse than no video at all?

 
  Xander479Xander479

It's up to the mod whether they verify or reject a no vid run. Usually things like that would be discussed before deciding to get a more general opinion than just one of the mods. A run not having audio isn't an insta-reject reason, but may be rejected if the mod thinks it's sketchy. Again, this would probably be brought up between mods because it's a lot easier to splice without audio.

Essentially, if the run looks sketchy the mod may reject it and video/sound are a couple ways to reduce the likelihood of this. (And no, there's no set time for which you HAVE to provide video for. That said, somebody coming out of the blue with a WR no video doesn't have great chances)

333Rich333333Rich333 likes this. 
  TwitchNameTwitchName

What reason would you have for not having video though lmfao

eddiecatgamingeddiecatgaming likes this. 
  Xander479Xander479

no access to a capture card, timing a run and not submitting for a while; losing the recording over that time etc. Usually it's not a problem to provide video proof, which is why most runs on the leaderboard do have video, but there's also no point in rejecting a 45 minute 11 Exit time for example.

 
  ChikoritaChikorita

Just my 2 cents, but you can record a run with a webcam, use a camera, or use a phone. Pretty sure a person would likely have access to one of those forms.

HowDenKingHowDenKing likes this. 
  StiversonStiverson

This was the first game I decided to speedrun, I ordered a capture card, but it took a couple weeks to ship from japan. While I waited I did speedruns and used livesplit to keep track of my times. I submitted my first times with only a splits.io. I can only state my opinion on the matter which is: I think it's a positive to the community to allow new runners to post early runs to the boards as long as they aren't top level times.

MaybeALegendMaybeALegend and Xander479Xander479 like this. 
Latest News
View all
No news
Recent Threads
View all
Thread Author
submitting runs with or without ms
Last post
oil_in_wateroil_in_water
2 replies
Dode's 1:23 removed?
Last post
SuperSpeedRunner14SuperSpeedRunner14
6 replies
New Category I've Been Working on For 2 Years
Last post
iiviigamesiiviigames
19 replies
Valid Emulators
Last post
IsoFriezeIsoFrieze
55 replies
exact fps
Last post
tdiogo_gamertdiogo_gamer
2 replies