Discussing a run I have rejected, and our current ruleset
8 days ago
Cumbria, England

A few years ago, an edit to the ruleset came about. Its intent was accessibility for runners who would be unable to play with RF off. Thanks to this we added four new runners to the board. My intent behind this rule addition was that a runner would change to Normal/RF off when ready. Originally the board had a firm rule against RF. When I first started speedrunning the game I found a run by HitSponge which used RF and was 8 seconds ahead of the WR at the time. It seemed reasonably clear to me after some play/experience that this feature makes Arcade Mode easier in a variety of ways, and top runners continued to keep RF off.

A run was submitted by GrayWarden, who currently holds second place on the board using Normal/RF OFF. The submission had Easy/RF ON with a time of 10:05. The runner is already capable of WR without using RF. I am disappointed not to have had the opportunity to discuss the options with you prior to your submission, as you so thoughtfully raised the use of Switch service to me recently in a separate thread. There is a post in the forums regarding precisely this from the time of the change. I am sorry for the lack of total clarity in the written rules however, and I'd be happy to discuss these with the community, as well as any other talking points.

Use of RF with grenade launcher can be a handicap against grunts at times, or an additional lag factor if misused. In my view however this is overridden by an overwhelming advantage on bosses and other stationary objects. This is reasonably clear, both from fights such as the panzer in stage 2, and because the run in question has several uncharacteristic errors for a top runner submission which do not lose time as expected. I invite readers to compare the runner's rejected run, and the 10:11 on the leaderboard.

Let us also look at a very old run by HitSponge using RF, of 10:07, which was for quite some time 8 seconds faster than fletchr's 10:15 wr, and was performed in 2013.

If I were applying the letter of the law alone, I would be forced to accept the new submission. However, with the points above considered, I judge that the runner has contravened the spirit of the ruleset in view of his existing second place time with RF off. The runner is at fault for failing to broach this before submission, however, I am also at fault for failing to make the ruleset crystal clear. For these reasons I reject this run. Please forgive the long nature of the post, but I should rather be transparent especially since as super, and wr holder, there may be seen a potential conflict of interest in my actions, which is not my intent.

I feel like the current ruleset suffices, perhaps we might add a rule recommending runners switch to Normal/RF OFF from approximately sub 10:50. All thoughts and feedback on the ruleset welcome.

Stirling, Scotland

Just to be clear, anyone who reads this thinking I tried to dupe the system, I didn't, I looked at the rules and in my eyes I followed them, I was running the game on easy with RF off to start but because I was running Marvel Land prior I ended up with a bit of thumb strain so I put RF on because I believe the rules allowed for the easy difficulty.

I'm not making a case for the decision to be reversed, what you are merely getting is my side and thoughts.

Having read peta's reasons for rejection I fully accept the reasons as I did have my doubts hence why I put Pending approval in the video

I would never, ever submit a false/fake run by any means as it is wrong and disrespectful to an amazing community.

This is a learning curve for me in the speedrunning industry and it is a lesson learned.

Peta, accept my apologies for any wrongdoing you feel I have done as it wasn't intended in any way

give us a shout if you wanna talk further, my door is always open

Статистика игры
Подписчики
23
Времена
86
Игроки
17
Последние темы
Опубликовано 7 days ago
1 ответ
Опубликовано 1 month ago
games:thread_reply_count
Опубликовано 1 year ago
games:thread_reply_count
Опубликовано 2 years ago
games:thread_reply_count
Опубликовано 3 years ago
games:thread_reply_count
Опубликовано 5 years ago
games:thread_reply_count
Модераторы