Game request got rejected without being looked at
Deleted
3 years ago
New York, USA

News flash. People keep requesting Among Us. Among Us keeps getting rejected. People keep complaining about this in the forum. Mods keep explaining why it won't be accepted. I don't know what you people think is changing.

miguelg, Ivory and 17 others like this
Israel

This game was probably added by the Minecraft series moderators, nothing to do with site staff.

Gaming_64, Hako and 3 others like this
New Jersey, USA

They were all added before rules got stricter. We don't remove games retroactively. By the standards now, almost none of them would be accepted.

Edited by the author 3 years ago
SuperAL1, ThatBox and 6 others like this
New Jersey, USA

Specifically for games related to the series, yes.

Specifically for Among Us, no. If anyone is found adding a game unrelated to the series, it will be considered moderator abuse and the leaderboard + the moderator will be removed.

Pear likes this
French Southern Territories

Your just removing the pvp aspect from a pvp based game like everyone else who has submitted among us.

MinecraftGaming, Hako and 2 others like this
New Brunswick, Canada

The issue is not in the category you are requesting being singleplayer, it's in the fact that 99% of the games popularity is in multiplayer. For example, the Overwatch leaderboard use to just be speedrunning the tutorial (also not a very good speedrun and would not be added onto the site with new rules) and there was no PvP categories, but over time they added more and more that were PvP related.

So the issue isn't with the run itself being a singleplayer run, but with the games community more than likely adding multiplayer categories over time.

And yes, site mods know it exists and have had lengthy discussions with other members of the speedrun community who have made the same arguments and claims as you have been.

Hako, Reverse and 3 others like this
Oregon, USA

For the people complaining about how often this keeps coming up, try to remember that most people do not look at the site forums at all, and that there isn't even a way to search the forums, so it's hardly a surprise that people keep submitting a popular new game and are surprised when it gets rejected. There's no reason to be mean when you see a new person post about it.

MrMonsh, WhenGryphonsFly and 5 others like this

Question to site staff: Why are series mods allowed to add PvP related games? Shouldn't this be... reconsidered?

cordeyr and XeroGoFast like this
California, USA

It should be explained further in the submission rules because the rules are vague. People keep submitting pvp games and posting about it because the rules are not clear and vague. They could mention in their own words that: they no longer accept pvp-games even though they did before; that pvp-based games already on the site are fine and will not be removed; that series mods can add pvp-based games to the site as long as they are not troll submissions (based on what I've seen in response to these submissions); and that in order for a pvp game to be accepted, it has to have some sort of PvE campaign or story mode.

ckellyspeedruns likes this