The mod of mcm_diversity keeps judging a large area as "grey area", and refuse to make more clear rule. I've post a possible addition rule, only to be locked and removed. Both-okay judging, I think, should be allowed just on ways that existing or not doesn't affect the game so much. A too undeclared rule just make the run a mess.
I'm sorry, I tried finding the exact ruling you are referring to and I can't find it, was it fixed?
The removed topic: I: Cavin856 is treating a whiter-than-intended as a grey area, so it should be necessary to define which extended rule is allowed. This is a legal rule sample:
- No placing or breaking blocks(including water, mushroom, or anything not an entity) from -1077 80 1790 to -1067 89 1800
- Redstone signal pointing to a bedrock is banned. This is NOT a legal rule sample:
- Block placing/breaking should be beautiful. This is NOT a legal rule sample:
- Everything is a grey area.
Directly "altering the redstone are prohibited." is a rule, but no longer an Any% rule, cuz it's not a probable existing rule in the game rule. Only limiting block placing/breaking is allowed.
Cavin856: This thread is unnecessary and meant to divide the community. We aren't at war, there is no need to argue. These "clear cut rules" don't mean anything, as there is no rule stating, for instance, that pointing a redstone signal into bedrock is banned. The prohibition is based on the word "implied" in rule #1 of this map. You are missing the entire point. I will not continue to explain the same thing over and over again. This thread will be locked immediately and deleted in 24 hours. Any additional threads made of a similar nature will be immediately deleted.
From what I can see, the rules seem pretty clear cut. It's not as specific as what you want, but it should be pretty easy to follow those rules.
the judging is somehow like "you have to cost more than 1 hr to have the record count", requiring players to use silly ways but factly same, and directly allowed